IFB vs RFP in Government Contracting: Complete Comparison Guide

Introduction

Government agencies use different procurement methods depending on project characteristics. The two primary methods—Invitation for Bid (IFB) and Request for Proposal (RFP)—require different bidding strategies and offer different selection criteria.

Understanding the differences helps you tailor your approach and maximize your competitiveness in each procurement type.

Quick Comparison

Aspect	IFB	RFP
Selection	Lowest price	Best value
Process	Sealed bid	Negotiated
Discussions	None	Possible

Invitation for Bid (IFB)

An IFB is a sealed bid procurement where the contract is awarded to the lowest responsive, responsible bidder. This is the traditional method for straightforward construction projects.

IFB Characteristics

Complete specifications provided
Clear, objective requirements
Price is the determining factor
Sealed bids opened publicly
No discussions or negotiations
Award to lowest qualified bidder

IFB Process

Agency issues IFB with complete specifications
Contractors submit sealed bids
Bids opened publicly at deadline
Agency determines responsive and responsible bidders
Award to lowest responsive, responsible bidder

Key Concepts

Term	Meaning
Responsive	Bid meets all formal requirements
Responsible	Bidder can perform the contract
Sealed Bid	Price unknown until public opening

Request for Proposal (RFP)

An RFP is a negotiated procurement where the agency evaluates multiple factors beyond price. This method allows for discussions and best value selection.

RFP Characteristics

Performance specifications or requirements
Multiple evaluation factors
Technical approach evaluated
Past performance considered
Discussions may occur
Best value selection

RFP Process

Agency issues RFP with evaluation criteria
Contractors submit proposals
Agency evaluates technical and price factors
Competitive range established (optional)
Discussions held (optional)
Final proposals requested
Award based on best value

Common Evaluation Factors

Technical approach and methodology
Past performance and experience
Key personnel qualifications
Management capability
Small business participation
Price/cost

Key Differences

Understanding these differences helps you prepare appropriately for each procurement type.

Factor	IFB	RFP
Selection Basis	Lowest price wins	Best value (price + other factors)
Specifications	Complete and detailed	Performance-based often
Discussions	Not permitted	May be held
Proposal Content	Price-focused	Technical + Price
Pursuit Cost	Lower	Higher
Evaluation Time	Faster	Longer
Price Revision	Not allowed	Possible in discussions

When Each Method is Used

Agencies select procurement method based on project characteristics.

IFB is Appropriate When:

Specifications are complete and detailed
Requirements are clear and objective
Price is the primary selection factor
Multiple qualified bidders available
Discussions are not necessary
Competitive sealed bidding is feasible

RFP is Appropriate When:

Technical approach varies among offerors
Past performance is important
Discussions may be needed
Best value matters more than lowest price
Complex or innovative solutions sought
Design-build or similar delivery methods

Construction Context

IFB: Most traditional design-bid-build construction
RFP: Design-build, complex projects, special expertise needed

Bidding Strategies

Different procurement methods require different approaches.

IFB Strategy

Focus on Price Competitiveness

Accurate quantity takeoffs
Competitive subcontractor pricing
Efficient means and methods
Minimal overhead and profit (within sustainability)
Complete, responsive bid package
Error-free submissions

RFP Strategy

Balance Price with Technical Excellence

Compelling technical approach
Relevant past performance
Qualified key personnel
Strong management plan
Competitive pricing
Professional proposal presentation

Resource Allocation

Activity	IFB Emphasis	RFP Emphasis
Estimating	High	High
Proposal Writing	Minimal	High
Past Performance	Basic documentation	Detailed narratives
Graphics/Presentation	Not needed	Often important

Proposal Tips for RFPs

RFP proposals require more than completing forms. Present your qualifications effectively.

Technical Proposal Tips

Address every evaluation criterion
Be specific, not generic
Demonstrate understanding of requirements
Explain your approach clearly
Highlight differentiators
Use compliant formatting

Past Performance Tips

Select most relevant projects
Match project characteristics to opportunity
Include quantifiable results
Alert references they may be contacted
Address any negative evaluations

Price Proposal Tips

Realistic, supportable pricing
Clear cost breakdown
Address price realism concerns
Balance competitiveness with capability

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an agency switch from IFB to RFP?

Yes, if circumstances change. If an IFB doesn't receive adequate competition or the agency determines discussions are needed, it may cancel and reissue as an RFP. This is relatively uncommon but does occur.

Is the lowest price always selected in an RFP?

No. RFPs allow best value selection, meaning the agency may pay more for a higher-rated technical proposal if the price premium is justified. The tradeoff analysis is documented in the source selection decision.

Can I improve my proposal after submission in an IFB?

No. IFBs are sealed bid procurements with no discussions. Your submitted price is final. This is why accuracy and completeness at submission are critical.

How important is price in an RFP?

It varies. The RFP must state the relative importance of factors. Some RFPs state price is most important; others say technical factors are equal or more important. Read the evaluation criteria carefully.

Conclusion

Success in government construction requires understanding both IFB and RFP procurement methods. Tailor your approach based on the procurement type: focus on competitive pricing for IFBs and balance price with technical excellence for RFPs.

Both methods offer opportunities. Build capabilities for both to maximize your competitive reach in government construction.

Find IFB and RFP Opportunities

ConstructionBids.ai aggregates government construction opportunities of all types. Find IFBs and RFPs matching your capabilities.

Start Finding Opportunities →